When Stars Collide
GENRE
COMEDY DRAMA SATIRE FUNNY ROMANCE
Core Theme
SECOND CHANCES/TRUE LOVE
TIME PERIOD
Contemporary,2000s
COMPARABLE TITLES
IF I NEVER MET YOU - MHAIRI MCFARLANE. NO, WE CAN'T BE FRIENDS - SOPHIE RANALD
CHARACTER LIST
MENA: PROTAGONIST. EARLY 30S. BOLD. INTELLIGENT. BLUNT. FEISTY AND DRIVEN.
ELLE: 30S. MENA’S SWEET AND COMPASSIONATE BEST FRIEND WHO LIVES IN VIRGINIA. MENA IS A PART OF ELLE'S BRIDAL PARTY.
LUKE: 30S. ELLE’S FIANCÉ AND A FRIEND OF MENA’S. HE SUFFERED A TRAUMATIC BRAIN INJURY AFTER AN ACCIDENT AND HAS TROUBLE WITH HIS MEMORY.
PETER MONROE: 30S. MENA’S GORGEOUS, THOUGHTFUL BOYFRIEND UNTIL HE BREAKS IT OFF WITH HER. HE LIVES IN VIRGINIA AND HAS A YOUNG SON.
JACKSON: PETER’S 7-YEAR-OLD SON. A SMART, FUNNY, AND BLUNT CHILD.
PHINEAS: 30S. MENA’S CHARISMATIC AND INCREDIBLY HANDSOME BOSS AT DRAKE PUBLISHING. MENA HAS A FLIRTY RELATIONSHIP WITH HIM.
Logline
Mena Straszewski has always lived life on her own terms. With a successful career in a New York publishing firm, she has life figured out. But when an unexpected event rocks her seemingly perfect world, she'll be forced to choose between the life she thought she wanted and the one she left behind.
Target Audiences
Age: 18-34,35-54
Target Gender: Female Leaning
Setting
New York City/Roanoke, Virginia
Based on a True Story
No
Publishing Details
Status: Yes: self-published
Publisher: Amazon
Year Published: 2020
Starting Description
Mena and her boyfriend, Peter, try to make their long-distance relationship work, with him commuting from his home in Virginia, and her commuting from New York. With Mena's career and Peter being a single father, moving isn't feasible and their breakup devastates Mena.
Ending Description
After months apart and a brief fling with her boss, Mena realizes that true happiness resides in the life she left behind so many years ago.
Group Specific
Information not completed
Hard Copy Available
Yes
ISBN
979-8636899037
Mature Audience Themes
Language/Profanity
Plot - Other Elements
Happy Ending
Plot - Premise
Other,Internal Journey/Rebirth
Main Character Details
Name: Mena Straszewski
Age: 33
Gender: Female
Role: Protagonist
Key Traits: Adventurous,Badass,Charming,Complex,Engaging,Educated,Leader,Outspoken,Funny,Sarcastic,Unapologetic,Blunt
Additional Character Details
Name: Peter Monroe
Age: 32
Gender: Male
Role: Emotional
Key Traits: Underdog,Masculine,Modest,Charming,Complex,Outspoken,Faithful,Romantic,Heartthrob,Sarcastic,Honorable,Unapologetic
Additional Character Details
Name: Phineas Drake
Age: 38
Gender: Male
Role: emotional
Key Traits: Adventurous,Masculine,Modest,Charming,Complex,Confident,Sexy,Decisive,Engaging,Outspoken,Skillful,Gracious,Visionary,Romantic,Heartthrob,Heroic,Educated,Seductive,Sophisticated,Honorable,Leader
Additional Character Details
Name: Elle Sloan
Age: 33
Gender: Female
Role: sidekick
Key Traits: Modest,Aspiring,Clumsy,Complex,Faithful,Gracious,Visionary,Romantic,Educated,Insecure
Genre
COMEDY, ROMANCE, DRAMA
Brief
Mena Straszewski has a great job at a New York City publishing firm, wonderful friends, a charming boss, and a boyfriend in Virginia who she loves. But when the distance puts a strain on her life and her relationship, she must evaluate what's most important to her, and whether she belongs in New York or in Virginia.
Overall Rating
GOOD
Narrative Elements
Authors Writing Style: GOOD
Characterization: GOOD
Commerciality: GOOD
Franchise Potential: FAIR
Pace: GOOD
Premise: GOOD
Structure: GOOD
Theme: GOOD
Accuracy of Book Profile
The Book Profile does accurately reflect this book for the most part, although noting "satire" as a genre feels a bit misleading.
Draw of Story
Mena is such a firecracker of a character. She has a big personality, a fun and distinct way of speaking, and a commanding presence. From the beginning of this story, I was drawn to Mena's personality and wanted the best for her. The writing in this story is also breezy, pleasant to read, and quirky.
Possible Drawbacks
At times Mena’s personality feels more cruel than just snarky and funny. Her behavior with Elle’s other bridesmaids in their first meeting, for example, felt a little meaner than it needed to be. Her harsh personality made it difficult for me to root for her at times and even made me want to take a break from the book every now and then. I would recommend softening her tone during the initial bridesmaids' meeting. Another issue is the fact that Peter’s character doesn’t jump off the page the same way that Phineas does. It feels as if Mena and Phineas have way more chemistry than Mena and Peter, and that feeling makes it hard to believe she would ever choose Peter over Phineas. Developing Peter's character more would help mitigate this issue.
Use of Special Effects
THE STORY DOES NOT RELY ON SPECIAL EFFECTS
Primary Hook of Story
Mena's interesting personality and character, as well as the memorable emotional ups and downs of this story would make me watch this movie.
Fanbase Potential
Yes. This project has the potential to appeal to several large fan bases. If adapted, this project could attract fans of young adult content, as well as romance and romantic comedy viewers.
Awards Potential
Because this would be a relatively lighthearted project, both in tone and in performance, it probably wouldn't have very much potential during awards' season apart from fan-voted awards.
Envisioned Budget
LOW BUDGET
Similar Films/TV Series
SWEET HOME ALABAMA. ALWAYS BE MY MAYBE. HOME AGAIN
What’s New About the Story
Mena is the most original aspect of this story. Her character feels like an original breath of fresh air. The ending also feels quite original, as it portrays moving back home to a smaller city as a positive step for Mena, rather than a failure in any way.
Lead Characters
Mena's bold and outlandish personality makes her stand out. Her sense of humor is particularly memorable. Elle's sweet personality makes her standout. She's patient, kind, and so loyal to Mena. Phineas' charm and decency makes him stand out. Because he's a gorgeous New York bachelor, it's a bit surprising that he's as genuine and sweet as he is.
Uniqueness of Story
I do believe this book is a rare gem in the romance/romantic comedy genre.
Possible Formats
Film - Indie, TV Series - Limited Run / Mini-Series
Analyst Recommendation
CONSIDER
Justification
For fans of the romance/romantic comedy genre, this book has all of the highs and lows to make it a wonderful and surprising read. Mena is a memorable character, and the supporting characters really jump off the pages as well. The plot is consistently exciting, with lots of unexpected twists and turns, and the pace is reliable and entertaining.
Brief
Mena Straszewski has a great job at a New York City publishing firm, wonderful friends, and a boyfriend in Virginia who she loves, but when distance and her charming boss put a strain on her relationship, Mena must evaluate what's most important to her, and whether she belongs in New York or in Virginia.
What We Liked
This is well paced, confidently written, and emotionally exciting story filled with unexpected twists and turns. Mena is a super unique main character. She’s quirky and competent, and she always says what she’s thinking. For the most part, it's incredibly easy to like her and root for her. This book is thematically impressive as well. The theme of second chance love is endearing. It's refreshing to read a book that looks at moving back home as a step forward, rather than a step backward.
Film: This project has a clear beginning, middle, and end that naturally lends itself to film. Mena's journey feels complete and emotionally satisfying by the end. Fans of romance, drama, and romantic comedy would love the ups and downs of Mena's romantic life. This project is also full of humor, as Mena is an exceptionally funny character.
TV: With a strong cast of supporting characters who all have their own distinct storylines, this project has plenty of potential stories to tell. From Elle's journey of meeting her father, to Jo's relationship realizations, to Mena's struggles with love, there are countless emotional journeys to explore. A TV adaptation would give this project the space it needs to really dive into the emotions of its stellar characters.
Key points: 1. Mena's memorable character 2. The vast and colorful cast of supporting characters 3. Strong, confident pacing 4. Dreamy love interests 5. Powerful and poignant emotional themes at play.
Synopsis
Mena is a driven young woman who works for a publishing company. She’s great at her job and she loves her life in New York City. But she also loves her boyfriend, Peter Monroe. Peter lives in Virginia and though Mena and Peter visit each other regularly, the distance is a problem for them. Still, Mena tries to focus on the positives as she takes on more responsibility at work and grows more intimate with Peter.
When Elle and Luke, two of Mena and Peter’s close friends, get engaged, it pushes Peter and Mena to examine their own relationship. Peter decides it’s time for Mena to finally meet his young son. She does, and the meeting goes quite well.
When Peter meets Mena’s boss, the charming and attractive Phineas, he sees how stable her life in NYC really is. But he also knows that until Jackson, his son, is older, he won’t be able to move from Virginia to New York. Mena and Peter love each other though, so they decide to keep giving this relationship a shot. Meanwhile, Elle takes a DNA test to confirm whether or not a man who contacted her online is really her father. Mena is supportive of her, and it’s clear that Elle has a lot of family turmoil. Mena meets Elle’s other bridesmaids and they pick their dresses for the wedding. At the meeting, one of the bridesmaids mentions a mole on Mena’s back that she doesn’t like the look of. Mena has it removed at the doctor, but thinks little of it.
Mena’s relationship with her boss grows closer when he invites her to a movie premiere and closer still when he saves her from a rude, overly touchy man at a chance meeting at a club. Mena and Phineas spend the rest of the night together. They open up to each other, and it’s clear there’s a lot of chemistry between the two of them. Nothing happens, but Mena does spend the night in Phineas’ room.
The next day, Peter calls and breaks up with Mena. He’s upset about the decision, but it’s one he seems confident about. They live in different worlds and unfortunately, Peter doesn’t seem to think it’s possible for those worlds to collide. Immediately after getting the news, a tearful Mena gets a call from Elle and learns that the man who contacted her online, Mark, is indeed her father.
Mena goes with Elle to meet her father. It is a joyous, tearful reunion. When she gets home, she tells Elle about her connection with Phineas after he texts her. Elle pokes fun at Mena, but she doesn’t push the subject.
Back at work, Mena hears back from the doctor about the mole she had removed. She learns she has melanoma. Phineas comforts her and she tells him about her breakup with Peter. Elle and Mena spot Peter with his child and ex-wife, happily walking down the street.
Two months later, Mena has surgery to determine just how bad the cancer is. When she wakes up, Elle and Luke are with her, but so it Phineas. Mena learns that the cancer hasn’t spread and she is cancer free currently. To celebrate, she goes with Phineas to the opera, where the two kiss passionately.
Phineas breaks things off in an effort to keep the relationship professional, but he still asks Mena to attend a red carpet event with him. She agrees, but is interrupted from dwelling on the moment when she gets a phone call from Elle. Peter’s father was killed in a car accident.
Mena and Phineas finally admit their feelings for each other and begin a relationship that is something like friends with benefits. Mena attends the funeral for Peter’s father, reconnects with Peter, and tells him she’s moved on with Phineas. Mena also discovers during Elle’s bachelorette party that Elle is pregnant.
With Elle and Luke’s wedding rapidly approaching, Mena begins to doubt her relationship with Phineas. Feelings she thought she had left behind for Peter start bubbling to the surface. Right as Mena begins to confront those feelings, Phineas arrives at the venue. Mena realizes that she really craves stability, but who can give it to her?
When Jackson runs away and Mena finds him, she realizes that she is still in love with Peter. Virginia is her home and it’s where she really wants to be. Phineas goes back to New York City after he and Mena end things.
Mena and Peter finally admit their feelings for each other at Luke and Elle’s beautiful wedding. One year later, Mena moves to Virginia, moves in with Peter, and works remotely for Drake Publishing. While it’s clear Phineas is hurting, he does his best to stay professional around Mena. In the final pages of the book, Peter proposes to Mena and she says yes.